| Boys | Girls | ||||
| 1999 | Kylen Compton | 1999 | Amanda Herr | ||
| 1998 | Jason Toten | 1998 | Sarah Seib | ||
| 1997 | Keith Schmitt | 1997 | Sarah Seib | ||
| 1996 | Scott Alvey | 1996 | Jennifer Donner | ||
| 1995 | Jerome Toten | 1995 | Jennifer Donner | ||
| 1994 | Mark Hanna | 1994 | Cathy Tepool | ||
| 1993 | Brian Arnold | 1993 | Krista Elpers | ||
| 1992 | Rodney Arnold | 1992 | Amy Whicker | ||
| 1991 | Jason Hunt | 1991 | Robin Tepool | ||
| 1990 | Chris Herr | 1990 | Tina Deal |